Best Apples for Apple Pie: How to Choose from Fall Orchard Varieties
Every November someone walks into our market with a recipe on their phone and asks the question that decides a pie before the oven is even on: "Which apples should I use?"
It matters more than the crust. Use the wrong apple and you get a soupy filling, a gap under the top crust, or slices that turn to applesauce. Use the right ones and the pie holds a clean wedge, tastes like fall, and disappears before the coffee is poured.
Our bakery turns out apple, Honeycrisp apple and caramel apple walnut pies every day at Ort Farms in Long Valley. Here's what we've learned about the best apples for apple pie, variety by variety, and the simple mixing rule that makes almost any pie better.
What makes an apple good for pie?
Three things decide it:
Firmness. A pie apple has to survive 45 minutes in a hot oven and still be a slice, not a puree. Firm, dense flesh wins.
Acidity. Sugar, butter and cinnamon are all sweet. Tartness is what keeps the filling from tasting flat.
Moisture. Juicy apples taste great raw and flood a pie. Drier-fleshed varieties bake cleaner.
No single apple is perfect on all three, which is why the best pies use more than one.
The best apples for apple pie, variety by variety
Granny Smith. The classic for a reason. Very firm, very tart, holds its shape better than almost anything. On its own it can be sharp; paired with a sweeter apple it's the backbone of a great pie.
Honeycrisp. Big, crisp and sweet-tart, with slices that stay intact. It's juicy, so give the filling a few minutes to release liquid before it goes in the crust. We bake a Honeycrisp-only pie because customers ask for it by name.
Jonagold. A cross of Jonathan and Golden Delicious. Large, honey-sweet with a tart edge, firm enough to hold. If you can only find one variety for a pie, this is a strong single choice.
Cortland. Tender, mildly tart, and slow to brown once cut, which makes it easy to work with. It softens more than Granny Smith, so use it as the "melting" layer in a mix rather than the whole pie.
Braeburn. Firm, spicy-sweet and dependable. Holds its shape and brings flavor without extra sugar.
Golden Delicious. Mellow and sweet, with thin skin that some bakers leave on. Pairs beautifully with Granny Smith; too soft to carry a pie alone.
Gala. Sweet, mild and a favorite for eating out of hand. In a pie it goes soft and tastes faint. Fine as one apple in a mix; not a lead.
McIntosh and Empire. Macs break down almost completely in the oven. That's wrong for a sliced pie and exactly right for a saucy, old-fashioned one. Empire, a Mac cross, is crisper and behaves more like Cortland.
The mixing rule our bakery trusts
For a standard nine-inch pie, think in thirds:
One third firm and tart. Granny Smith or Braeburn. This is your structure.
One third sweet and crisp. Honeycrisp or Jonagold. This is your flavor.
One third tender. Cortland or Golden Delicious. This softens into the gaps and binds the slices together.
Plan on about three pounds of apples, roughly six to eight medium ones, per pie.
Slice them a quarter-inch thick so they cook evenly, and toss with the sugar and spice for 20 to 30 minutes before filling the crust. The juice that collects can be poured off or simmered down and added back, which is the single best fix for the gap between filling and top crust.
Where the apples come from at Ort Farms
In fall our farm market is stocked with our own apples from the orchard, plus hand-selected fruit from nearby growers like Melick's Town Farm, Larchmont
Orchards and Bechdolt Orchards. That mix is why you'll usually find several pie varieties on the shelf at once, even after our pick-your-own season ends.
Apple picking at Ort Farms runs from late summer through the fall, and different varieties ripen at different times, so what you can pick changes week to week. If you want to bake with apples you picked yourself, come in September or early October and check our Apple Picking page or our social media for the current variety report.
And if the pie is the goal but the baking isn't, our bakery makes apple, Honeycrisp apple and caramel apple walnut pies fresh daily. Around Thanksgiving, pumpkin pie is our top seller and apple is right behind it. You can order ahead online for pickup at the market.
5 small things that make a big difference
Use fresh, firm apples. An apple that's been in the fruit bowl for three weeks bakes mushy. Press the skin; it should not give.
Peel most of them. Skins go leathery in the oven. Leaving one thin-skinned Golden Delicious unpeeled adds color without the chew.
Go easy on sugar when using sweet varieties. Honeycrisp and Jonagold bring their own. Cut the recipe's sugar by a quarter and taste.
Add a squeeze of lemon. It brightens sweet apples and keeps slices from browning while you work.
Let it cool. The filling sets as it cools. Cut a pie straight from the oven and it slides; wait two hours and it slices.
Why buying apples from a farm matters
Apples from a farm market were picked days ago, not months, which is why they're firmer in the pie.
There's a bigger reason too. New Jersey farms depend on visitors more than farms almost anywhere else: research in the Journal of Food Distribution Research found the state ranks first in the nation for the share of farm income that comes from agritourism, and a Rutgers study found every dollar spent at a New Jersey farm generates another 58 cents for nearby businesses.
The bag of apples for your pie keeps an orchard in business.
Apple pie FAQs
How many apples do I need for one pie?
About three pounds, which is six to eight medium apples, for a nine-inch pie. Buy one extra in case of a bruise.
Can I make apple pie with just one variety?
Yes. Jonagold, Honeycrisp or Braeburn each work alone. Granny Smith alone is tart; add a little extra sugar. Avoid Gala or McIntosh as the only apple unless you want a soft, saucy filling.
Which apples are best for apple crisp or crumble?
The same rules apply, but crisps forgive softer apples. Cortland and Golden Delicious shine here, and a Mac or two adds sauce.
Can I freeze apples for pie?
Yes. Peel, slice, toss with a little lemon juice and freeze flat on a tray before bagging. Bake from frozen and add 10 to 15 minutes to the time.
Does Ort Farms sell pie apples after picking season ends?
Yes. Our market carries apples through the fall and into the holidays, from our own orchard and nearby growers. Varieties change with the harvest, so ask at the counter for what's baking best this week.
The short answer
The best apples for apple pie are firm, tart and dry enough to hold a slice: Granny Smith for structure, Honeycrisp or Jonagold for flavor, Cortland or Golden Delicious to tie it together. Mix them, slice them thin, let them sit, and cool the pie before you cut it.
Or let us do it. For generations, Ort Farms has grown apples and baked pies in Long Valley, and our bakery is open every day the market is. Stop in for a bag of apples, a pie, or both.



